Heavy Metals in Baby Food?
This post may contain affiliate links. If you choose to purchase a product through a link, I will receive a small commission - this in no way impacts the amount you pay. Affiliate links are marked with an asterisk (*).
In recent years, there has been a great deal of concern about heavy metals in baby food, sparking debates and prompting regulatory scrutiny. Parents, healthcare providers, and policymakers alike are increasingly worried about the potential health risks associated with these contaminants in products meant for our youngest consumers - infants and young children.
As a pediatric registered dietitian, I cannot tell you how many panicked direct messages, comments, and texts I’ve received over the years about fear of heavy metal exposure. Rest assured, we haven’t poisoned our children by feeding them commercial baby foods, and while the recent findings are certainly concerning and not to be ignored, it’s also not necessary to bag up all your commercial baby food and throw it in the trash.
In this post, I’ll review the complexities of heavy metal contamination in baby food, address the new regulations, and discuss ways to mitigate child exposure to toxic heavy metals from the food supply. As we continue to navigate these issues, staying informed and advocating for greater transparency and accountability in food production will be key to protecting the health of our little ones now and in the future.
What are Heavy Metals?
Heavy metals are elements that occur naturally and can be found in the Earth’s crust. They include substances like lead, arsenic, mercury, and cadmium, which can pose health risks when consumed in excessive amounts.
A variety of metals and minerals are found in small amounts in many foods, and some are important for growth and development, such as iron, copper, and zinc
Why are Heavy Metals in Baby Food?
The presence of heavy metals in baby food can be attributed to several factors, such as soil and water contamination, industrial processes, and agricultural practices. They can enter the food chain through soil, water, and air. Plants absorb these metals from soil and water, which can then be transferred into foods we eat, including baby food.
Pollution, mining, and manufacturing processes can release heavy metals into the environment and water sources. Some pesticides and fertilizers may also contain heavy metals and toxic elements, which can accumulate in crops.
The processing of foods, including baby foods, can also sometimes introduce heavy metals. Contamination may occur during harvesting, storage, transportation, and processing stages, especially if equipment or containers containing heavy metals are used.
Can Heavy Metals Harm My Baby?
Yes, excessive amounts of heavy metals can potentially harm a baby, especially because infants and young children are more vulnerable to the effects of these substances. Here’s how different heavy metals can impact a baby’s health:
Lead: Even small amounts of lead can affect a child’s development, leading to learning disabilities, decreased IQ, behavioral problems, and developmental delays. Lead can interfere with the development of the nervous system and cause long-term neurological effects.
Arsenic: Chronic exposure to arsenic has been linked to an increased risk of various health problems, including skin lesions, developmental effects, cardiovascular disease, and certain types of cancer. In infants and young children, arsenic exposure can affect growth and development.
Mercury: Exposure to mercury can affect the nervous system, impair cognitive development, and cause brain damage. In developing fetuses and young children, mercury exposure can lead to delays in walking and talking, as well as coordination difficulties.
Cadmium: Cadmium exposure can impair kidney function, cause bone damage, and impact lung health. Children exposed to cadmium may experience growth delays and developmental issues.
The harmful effects of these heavy metals on the human body depend on several factors, including the level and duration of exposure. Infants and young children are particularly at risk because their bodies are small and still developing, and their organs, especially the brain, are more sensitive to toxins.
Who regulates heavy metals in baby foods?
To address concerns about heavy metals in foods, regulatory bodies like the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) have been actively involved in monitoring and regulating heavy metals levels in baby food and other consumer products.
However, the heavy metal testing and regulation processes are complex and evolving, often requiring ongoing adjustments based on new scientific findings and detection methods.
What are the current updates on heavy metals in baby foods?
Recent studies have highlighted varying levels of heavy metals in apple juice and baby foods, including popular products like rice cereals, other fruit juices, and vegetable purees. A 2019 study by Healthy Babies, Bright Futures found that 95% of baby foods they tested contained heavy metals.
Recent findings by a congressional report released on February 4, 2021 also found arsenic, lead, cadmium, and mercury in some brands of baby food. These findings have led to calls for stricter standards and more transparent labeling practices.
In response to high levels of heavy metals found in baby foods, lawmakers have introduced the Baby Food Safety Act of 2024, which seeks to tighten regulations and increase enforcement by the FDA. The bill aims to set limits on contaminants like lead and arsenic in all baby food products, not just infant rice cereal, and enforce stricter testing and mandatory recalls. It is long overdue but a great start to making the necessary changes to baby food regulations.
How to Reduce Exposure to Heavy Metals in Baby Foods
While complete avoidance of heavy metals in foods may be challenging due to their natural presence and ubiquitous nature, there are steps we can take to reduce exposure:
1. Diversify the Diet: As a pediatric registered dietitian, I find myself constantly talking about the importance of a varied diet. Dietary variety is key in public health for so many reasons! Different foods offer different nutrients, and babies need a wide spectrum of nutrients from all the food groups in order to thrive and grow. But when it comes to heavy metals, by offering a wide variety of foods early in life, you’re also helping to ensure that your baby has limited exposure to any one specific contaminant.
2. Choose Trusted Brands with Minimally Processed, Nutrient-Rich Foods: Look for baby foods from manufacturers that prioritize safety and quality testing. Look for verification by the Clean Label Project, which is a national nonprofit that tests hundreds of products (including baby food) for toxic metals and contaminants. Clean Label Project verified brands are dedicated to consumer transparency, and already taking extra steps to minimize any chemicals of concern in their products. A few examples include Love Child Organics, Serenity Kids*, Once Upon a Farm, and Cerebelly*.
3. Stay on top of your child’s iron status: People who are iron deficient absorb about 2-3x as much lead as those who don’t have an iron deficiency. And iron is essential for overall growth, brain development, and immune health during childhood anyway, so prioritize iron-rich foods in meals and snacks for babies and kids, which include foods like beans, lentils, eggs, tofu, whole grains, meats, poultry, and fortified cereals.
4. Don’t beat yourself up!: If you’re a parent or caregiver who has fed your baby puffs, rice cereal, or jars and pouches of baby food, please don’t feel like you poisoned your baby. Some people are struggling enough to feed their families, and some food is always better than no food. Our collective energy is much better spent focusing on a demand for higher standards and better reporting from the FDA, as well as more transparency from brands around manufacturing practices.
Are organic baby foods free from heavy metals?
Organic baby foods, which are grown without synthetic pesticides and fertilizers, are not necessarily free from heavy metals. Heavy metals like lead, arsenic, cadmium, and mercury are naturally present in the environment, including the soil and the water supply in some areas. Organic farming practices do not prevent these metals from being absorbed by plants through soil or water contamination.
Additionally, organic farms may still be located in areas where heavy metals are naturally present or where there may be contamination from nearby industrial activities, traffic emissions, or other sources.
Contamination can also occur during the processing, handling, and packaging of organic foods, including baby foods. Equipment or containers used in processing may contain traces of heavy metals, which can transfer to the final product.
The problem isn’t necessarily with baby food, it’s with the ingredients used to make it, regardless of whether they are organically or conventionally grown.
Which baby foods are most concerning regarding heavy metals?
The biggest concern from recent reports seems to be the presence of arsenic in rice-based baby foods like puffs, rice cereal, and teething biscuits - foods that are not particularly nutrient-rich.
Because of the way it grows, rice, a common ingredient in many commercial baby foods, tends to have higher levels of arsenic than other grains like oats, barley, wheat, and buckwheat. For years, the recommendation was to start solids with baby rice cereal (and some pediatricians are still providing this outdated advice); however, we now know that there are healthier alternatives with which to begin.
At the margins, consider limiting rice and rice-based foods and, instead, choose more nutrient-rich alternatives as often as you can, such as oatmeal* or cereals made with whole grains* like barley or quinoa. Instead of puffs or other baby snacks made with rice, choose alternatives like freeze-dried* fruit/yogurt or one of my favorites for top allergen exposure, Mission Mighty Me Puffs*.
If your family enjoys rice, here is an evidence-based recipe on how to cook rice in such a way that it lowers arsenic content. And here are some brands and types that are lower in arsenic to begin with:
Blue Moon Acres rice
Lundberg brown rice grown in California
Rice grown in Madagascar
Basmati rice imported from India and Pakistan and jasmine rice from Thailand (according to this article)
“Mighty Rice” brand grown on the Mauritius island near the Indian Ocean
Rice alternatives: Banza Chickpea “Rice”
Many other common ingredients used to make commercial baby food tend to have comparatively higher levels of heavy metals as well, like carrots and sweet potatoes, which doesn’t mean these foods are “bad.” It just means that it is important to offer them as a part of a wide variety of foods, rather than offering them to babies every day or multiple times throughout the day.
**TOP TIP**: An effective way to reduce exposure to lead and help prevent lead poisoning in babies and children is to avoid fruit juice in babies under 12 months and offer it sparingly beyond one year of age. (While the FDA did release action levels for lead in juice in April of 2022, the American Academy of Pediatrics recommends avoiding juice for babies under a year anyway to help protect breast milk and/or formula intake. They also recommend limiting fruit juice to less than 4-6 ounces per day in toddlers and children to help protect their teeth from dental caries and maintain their appetites for nutrient-dense food.)
Final thoughts…
There’s no need to go and throw out all of your commercial baby food. Processed baby foods can still be folded into a balanced, varied diet by stretching them out over longer periods of time and serving them along with a variety of other foods.
The presence of heavy metals in baby food is a serious concern that requires ongoing attention from both industry stakeholders and regulatory bodies. While efforts are being made to improve testing and regulatory standards, informed consumer choices remain crucial in protecting the health of babies and children.
By working together to address these challenges, we can better ensure that baby foods are safe, nutritious, and supportive of healthy development. If you would like to take action, contact your congressman and senators to advocate further for stricter limits on contaminants and more manufacturing transparency from brands.
If you’re getting ready to start your baby on solids, download my FREE BLW Starter Guide. It includes my top expert tips for successfully introducing solids, a short list of budget-friendly baby-led feeding tools, a printable 1-sheet for your baby’s caregivers, first food ideas and how to safely serve them, PLUS a 5-Day packable BLW meal plan with photos for food sizing to make your life easier.
You can also check out my online course for parents, based on my best-selling book, which will walk you through the whole process of starting solids and introducing top allergenic foods using a baby-led approach and includes 12 weeks of meal plans that map out the entire first 3 months of your baby’s solid food feeding journey.
If you prefer books and want help with starting solids, finding recipes the whole family (baby included) can enjoy, and navigating food allergy prevention during infancy all at the same time, check out my new cookbook and guide to starting solids and introducing allergens! It gives you the latest research on safely introducing all top 9 allergens and 80 baby-friendly recipes plus tips to help you continue offering allergens consistently.
Thanks for reading!
8-month old baby girl eating oats with berries. Thank you to her wonderful parents for allowing to share!